
Exempt vs. Non-Exempt: How Colorado Employers Classify Employees
Exempt or non-exempt? How Colorado employers classify a role under federal law and the COMPS Order, with Colorado's 2026 salary threshold and what to do about a mistake.




By Allisha McCartney1 Oct 202614 min read

If you run a business in Colorado, you've probably wondered whether you're paying overtime the right way, whether your team gets the breaks the law requires, what has to be on a pay stub and how fast a final paycheck needs to go out. The answers mostly live in two laws, the Colorado Wage Act and the COMPS Order.
The Wage Act covers how and when you pay people, including the last paycheck. The COMPS Order covers what you pay and how work time is handled: the minimum wage, overtime, meal and rest breaks, pay records and a poster you're required to display. Below, I walk through both in plain English with the 2026 figures from the Colorado Department of Labor and Employment (CDLE), so you know what applies to you and what to do about it. If you'd like the bigger picture first, my guide to Colorado employment law covers the other rules small employers run into.
Federal wage law, the Fair Labor Standards Act, applies in Colorado too. Where Colorado, federal and local rules overlap, CDLE's rule is that the law giving more protection, or setting the higher standard, is the one you follow.
The Colorado Wage Act is the state law about paying wages: how often, how, what you can deduct, and what happens when someone leaves. Once a team member earns wages, the Wage Act protects their right to be paid, whether the amount was set by law, by an agreement or by your usual practice.
Every employer needs regular pay periods no longer than one calendar month or 30 days, whichever is longer, with payday no more than 10 days after each pay period ends. You also need to post a notice of your regular paydays and the time and place of payment, at the workplace or somewhere else team members can easily see it. An electronic posting works too, as long as it's easy for your team to get to.
Deductions are limited to the ones the law allows. CDLE's poster gives examples of what isn't allowed, such as deductions for poor work, breakage or quitting without notice. You can pay different rates for different work if you and the team member agree on each rate before the work is done, although you can't lower a rate after the fact for work that's already been performed.
When a deduction feels fair to you (a broken tool, for example), it's worth checking CDLE's guidance before it goes on a paycheck. CDLE explains these rules in short interpretive notices called INFOs, all posted on its INFOs page.
COMPS stands for the Colorado Overtime and Minimum Pay Standards Order. CDLE's Division of Labor Standards and Statistics issues it, and the current version is COMPS Order #40, effective February 1, 2026. The yearly dollar figures, like the minimum wage and the exempt salary level, come from a companion order called the PAY CALC Order, and the 2026 figures have applied since January 1, 2026.
The COMPS Order covers all private-sector work except the jobs and employers it exempts. It covers employees, not independent contractors, and whether someone is a contractor depends on the actual facts of the work, not just on what a contract or a 1099 says.
For 2026, the Colorado minimum wage is $15.16 per hour. It applies to everyone the COMPS Order covers, including team members paid by salary, commission or piece rate, whose pay has to work out to at least the minimum wage for all time worked.
Tipped team members are the ones who regularly receive more than $1.64 per hour in tips. For 2026, you can pay them $12.14 per hour by taking a tip credit of up to $3.02, but only to the extent their tips bring total pay up to the full $15.16. If tips fall short, you pay the difference.
Some Colorado cities and counties set a higher local minimum wage for work done there, and you pay the highest minimum that applies. Denver's is $19.29 per hour for 2026, for example. CDLE's local minimum wage guidance (INFO #19 on the INFOs page) lists each one.
Every employer covered by the COMPS Order has to display the current year's COMPS poster where team members can easily read it during the workday. If a physical poster doesn't work, for example with remote team members, you give each person a copy within their first month. CDLE releases a new version by each December, and you'll find it on the CDLE posters page in English and 16 other languages.
Two poster rules are easy to miss. If you hand out a handbook or written policies, a copy of the COMPS Order or poster has to go with it, and if team members sign for the handbook, they sign an acknowledgment for the poster too. If you don't post as required, you lose the right to use the COMPS Order's employee-specific credits, deductions and exemptions.
CDLE has proposed a new COMPS Order and a 2027 PAY CALC Order, with a public hearing set for November 2, 2026 and a planned effective date of January 1, 2027. Nothing is final yet, so I'd wait for the adopted version and the new poster before changing anything. My post on new Colorado employment laws covers what has already changed this year.
Colorado overtime is one and a half times a team member's regular rate of pay for hours over 40 in a workweek, over 12 in a workday, or over 12 consecutive hours, whichever gives the team member more pay. The daily and consecutive-hour rules matter for anyone running long shifts: a team member who works past 12 hours in a single day is owed overtime for those extra hours, even in a week that stays under 40 hours.
Three more overtime rules apply:
Paying someone a salary doesn't, on its own, make them exempt from overtime. For the executive or supervisor, administrative and professional exemptions, the job has to meet the duties tests in the COMPS Order and pay a salary of at least $57,784 a year for 2026 ($1,111.23 a week). A team member who misses either test is non-exempt, and you can still pay them a salary, with overtime pay added for any overtime hours.
The exempt salary level is adjusted for inflation every year, so it's worth reviewing your exempt roles each January, along with your minimum wage rates. If a role sits close to the line, your options are generally to pay the exempt salary, pay hourly with overtime, or arrange schedules to keep overtime down.
Colorado requires both meal periods and rest periods, and they work differently. Meal periods can be unpaid when the rules are met, while rest periods are always paid and count as time worked.
When a shift runs over 5 hours, the team member is entitled to an uninterrupted 30-minute meal period with no work duties. It can be unpaid only if they're completely relieved of all duties, allowed to leave the work site and allowed to do personal activities. As far as practical, the meal period should fall at least an hour after the shift starts and at least an hour before it ends.
If the work truly makes an uninterrupted meal period impractical, the team member must be allowed to eat while working, and that time is paid. CDLE is clear that being busy isn't enough: a store that can stagger its cashiers' meal periods can't call every meal period impractical. A single overnight clerk who has to stay on duty for the whole shift is the kind of case where a paid, on-duty meal is allowed.
Rest periods are a paid 10 minutes for every 4 hours worked, or major fraction of 4 hours. By shift length, that works out to:
Rest periods should fall in the middle of each 4-hour stretch where practical, and team members don't have to leave the premises, although they can't be working. If a required rest period isn't authorized and permitted, you owe extra pay for that time, and that applies to team members who aren't paid hourly as well. The simplest fix is usually the schedule itself: put breaks on it rather than leaving them to whoever has a quiet minute.
Colorado calls a pay stub an itemized earnings statement, and you owe one to each team member every pay period. The Colorado Wage Act and CDLE's pay rule each list what it has to show, and the list below combines them:
If a payroll provider produces your stubs, it's worth comparing a real one against that list. I don't process payroll, but I do help with wage and hour compliance and with choosing a payroll provider, and that day-to-day help is part of HR Operations Support.
Behind each stub, the COMPS Order expects you to keep records for every team member: name, address, job, hire date (and date of birth if they're under 18), a daily record of hours worked, credits and tips, and pay details for each pay period. Keep them for at least 3 years after the wages were due, and for as long as any wage claim is pending. My HR & Payroll Record Retention Toolkit covers how long to keep each type of record, with the general federal and Colorado requirement and my recommendation.
New this year, COMPS Order #40 also has you keep records of vacation or PTO hours accrued, used and available in the current benefit year, plus paid sick leave hours if you track those separately. When a team member asks, you provide their vacation balance in writing or electronically, and they can ask once a month, or more often if your policy allows. Listing balances on each pay stub or in an online portal are both reasonable ways to handle it.
Final pay timing depends on who ended the job. When you fire or lay off a team member, all wages owed are due immediately. If your payroll unit isn't regularly scheduled to be working at that moment, the pay has to be available within six hours of the start of its next regular workday, or, if payroll is handled off-site, delivered within 24 hours of the start of its next regular workday to the worksite, your local office or the team member's last known mailing address.
When a team member quits, final pay is due by the next regular payday. If you send a final check to the worksite or your local office and the person still hasn't received it 60 days after it was due, you mail it instead.
If you offer paid vacation, earned and unused vacation is part of final pay, whether the person was fired, laid off or resigned, with or without notice. A policy that says earned vacation is forfeited when someone leaves can't be enforced, although you can still set a cap on how much vacation people can build up. What counts is how the leave works, not what it's called: PTO or personal days that can be used for any purpose count as vacation, while leave that can only be used for set reasons, like sick leave or bereavement, doesn't have to be paid out.
The deduction limits still apply to a final paycheck, so you can't deduct for quitting without notice. If you need to confirm that company property or money was returned, you may take up to 10 days to audit, with written notice and other conditions for any deduction that follows. If a former team member sends a written demand for wages, or CDLE sends a notice of complaint, pay everything owed within 14 days after it's sent to avoid penalties.
Before a termination meeting, it helps to have the final check calculated, earned vacation included, so you can hand it over the same day. If your payroll provider needs lead time, build that into when you schedule the conversation.
If you'd like a place to start, these questions cover most of what's above:
If a few of those gave you pause, you're not behind for asking. Wage and hour rules are part of what I help owners sort out through HR Foundations & Compliance. I start by learning a bit about your business, then give you a short, practical ranked list of what to fix first.
It does, and paying a salary doesn't change that. Team members the COMPS Order covers must receive at least the Colorado minimum wage for all time worked, even when they're paid by salary, commission or piece rate, and that minimum is $15.16 per hour for 2026. A salary that works out to less than that for the hours actually worked falls short, even if the person is paid the same amount every week.
No, the COMPS Order doesn't allow it. Time off can't replace time-and-a-half pay for overtime hours, and you can't average a long week against a short one to avoid overtime. If you want to keep overtime down, the options are arranging schedules, paying hourly with overtime, or paying an exempt salary to roles that genuinely meet the exemption tests.
It depends on how the job ended. If you fire or lay off a team member, final wages are due immediately, with a short window when your payroll unit isn't working at that moment: six hours from the start of its next regular workday, or 24 hours if payroll is off-site. If a team member quits, final pay is due by the next regular payday.
If the PTO can be used for any purpose, Colorado treats it as vacation pay, and earned, unused hours have to be paid out when the person leaves, whatever the reason. Leave that can only be used for specific reasons, such as sick leave or bereavement leave, doesn't have to be paid out. A policy that forfeits earned vacation can't be enforced.
The poster changes every year. CDLE releases a new version by each December, and you're expected to display the poster for the current year. The 2026 poster shows the $15.16 minimum wage and the $57,784 exempt salary level.
Subscribe to my newsletter
Join my email list to hear when I release new HR resources for small businesses, plus Colorado HR updates.
Thanks, you're on my list.

Exempt or non-exempt? How Colorado employers classify a role under federal law and the COMPS Order, with Colorado's 2026 salary threshold and what to do about a mistake.
Read more
Many Colorado employment laws apply from your first hire. Here's what small employers need to know about wages, sick leave, FAMLI, pay transparency, hiring and final pay.
Read more
Colorado's paid sick leave law applies to every employer. Here's what owners and managers need to set up: accrual, carryover, allowed uses, pay, notices and your PTO policy.
Read moreHR Fit Check
Tell me a little about your team and I'll point you to the service that fits your business and the way of working together that suits you.
Take the Fit CheckTake the Fit Check