
HR Metrics and KPIs That Matter for Small Businesses
The HR metrics worth tracking in a small business: headcount, turnover, early turnover, time to hire and cost per hire, with a simple monthly HR report.




By Allisha McCartney10 Nov 20269 min read
Subscribe to my newsletter
Join my email list to hear when I release new HR resources for small businesses, plus Colorado HR updates.
Thanks, you're on my list.
Subscribe to my newsletter
Join my email list to hear when I release new HR resources for small businesses, plus Colorado HR updates.
Thanks, you're on my list.

Who should run your payroll, carry your benefits and help you with the people side of the business? You have three main options: signing with a PEO, hiring an ASO, or bringing in an HR consultant. The labels sound alike, but they split the work, the tax responsibility and the control over your team in different ways.
I'll cover what each one does, how each is priced, how much say you keep, and what Colorado law expects from a PEO. You should also know where I stand. HRish Solutions isn't a PEO, and I don't process payroll. I'm an HR consultant, and I'll be clear about where my kind of help fits and where it doesn't.
A PEO, short for professional employer organization, takes over the employer side of payroll for your team. According to the IRS, a PEO takes on payroll administration and tax reporting for the businesses it serves and is typically paid a fee based on payroll costs.
Colorado's law has a name for the arrangement. The Colorado Employment Security Act calls the PEO an "employee leasing company", calls your business the "work-site employer", and calls you and the PEO coemployers: the rights and duties of an employer are divided between you by the contract. Under that law, the PEO pays wages and pays the payroll-related taxes and premiums from its own accounts for the team members it covers, and it keeps their employee records. It can also group all of its clients' team members together to sponsor workers' compensation, fully insured health plans and retirement plans. If your benefits come through a PEO, ask early what happens to those plans if you ever leave.
At the federal level, a PEO can choose to apply for the IRS's voluntary certification program. Becoming a Certified Professional Employer Organization (CPEO) means the PEO has met the IRS's background, experience, business location, financial reporting, tax compliance and bonding requirements. Certification changes who owes the federal employment taxes. Generally, a CPEO is solely liable for those taxes on the wages it pays to work-site employees, although you and the CPEO may both be liable for wages it pays to anyone who isn't a work-site employee.
Without that certification, the IRS's general rule for outsourced payroll applies. The IRS reminds employers that they're ultimately responsible for the income tax withheld and for both the employer and employee shares of Social Security and Medicare taxes, with one exception: in certain situations, customers of a CPEO are relieved of that liability.
An ASO, short for administrative services organization, is an outside vendor that handles specific HR tasks for you, such as payroll, benefits administration and other HR paperwork. It doesn't co-employ your team or share your liabilities. Your business stays the only employer, and the ASO works for you under an ordinary vendor agreement.
Don't confuse it with an ASO health plan. In insurance, the same letters stand for an administrative services-only plan, where a business self-funds its benefits and has a third party manage them. That's a benefits funding arrangement, a different product from an HR ASO.
Payroll taxes are where an ASO and a PEO part ways. When an ASO runs your payroll, the payroll goes under your own business's EIN (employer identification number), so your business stays liable. The IRS's third-party arrangement chart spells out the same rule for any payroll service provider: the provider can prepare your returns and make your deposits, but you, not the provider, remain liable for filing on time and paying on time. If the provider defaults, you're still responsible for the deposits and the returns.
An ASO is worth a look if you want to stay the only employer and keep choosing your own benefits plans, but you'd rather not process the payroll and benefits paperwork in-house. Before you sign, find out exactly which tasks it covers, since each one is spelled out in the contract.
A PEO and an ASO mostly take administration off your plate. Whichever one runs your payroll, the people side still lands with you: a policy that fits how you work, a hire, a complaint, a manager who needs backup before a hard conversation. That's the part an HR consultant helps with.
It's the work I do. I absolutely am not a PEO, and I don't run anyone's payroll. I help with wage and hour compliance and with choosing a payroll provider. I'm not a benefits broker either, but I help you find one, choose plans that fit and get through enrollment. Usually the final calls and the day-to-day people management stay with you, though it depends on the business.
If you want that help on an ongoing basis rather than one project at a time, a fractional HR partner is the consultant option that keeps coming back month after month. My post on what fractional HR is explains how that arrangement works and how to tell whether you're ready for it.
You don't have to choose just one. You can keep a payroll provider or an ASO for the administration and bring in a consultant for the people side. Working with me doesn't mean switching anything: your team, your payroll and your providers stay as they are, and I work alongside them.
When I help a client choose an HR system, I start with what the system needs to do before any vendor demo, and I look at headcount, budget, payroll setup and the tools already in place. The same order works when you compare PEOs and ASOs. Decide what you want handed off before the sales calls start, and you'll find the proposals much easier to compare.
Each of the three is priced its own way, so lining up quotes side by side takes some care. Here's how each one generally charges, and how much say you keep:
Control is where the contract matters most with a PEO. For a PEO to count as a coemployer under Colorado's unemployment law, its contract has to give it certain rights, including the right to set pay rates, to direct and control the team members it covers (a right it can share with you) and to hire, reassign or discharge them. The more of the employer role you hand over, the more of it you share, so read those sections of the contract before anything else.
If you're looking at a PEO in Colorado, it helps to know how the state treats one. The Colorado Department of Labor and Employment (CDLE) notes that a professional employer organization is also referred to as an employee leasing company. Colorado's Employment Security Act then sets a few rules that affect you as the client:
These are the questions I'd ask any PEO before signing:
On that last question, whoever keeps the files, you should know what has to be kept and for how long. My Record Retention Toolkit lists the general federal and state requirements and my recommendation for each type of record.
If you'd rather keep your own payroll and benefits and get help with the HR around them, that's what my HR Operations Support service covers: day-to-day HR questions, files, leave, systems, and HR support around payroll and benefits.
A PEO becomes a coemployer of your team, pays wages and payroll taxes from its own accounts, and can sponsor benefits plans for its clients' team members. An ASO handles specific HR and payroll tasks for you under a vendor agreement, and your business stays the only employer and stays liable for its payroll taxes.
You still run your team day to day, but the contract decides which employer rights the PEO holds. Under Colorado's unemployment law, a PEO counts as a coemployer only if its contract gives it certain rights, such as setting pay rates, directing team members (which it can share with you) and hiring, reassigning or discharging. Anything the contract doesn't specifically give the PEO stays with your business.
The IRS publishes a list of certified PEOs, updated by the 15th day of the first month of every calendar quarter, along with lists of PEOs whose certification has been suspended or revoked. The names of many CPEOs are similar, so compare the exact name and EIN in your contract with the list.
If the IRS suspends a CPEO's certification, the CPEO must give each customer written notice within 10 days of the effective date of the suspension. If the certification is revoked, the CPEO must also notify each customer in writing, and from the date the revocation takes effect, you may also be liable for federal employment taxes on the wages it pays your team.
No. You can keep a payroll provider or an ASO for the administration and work with an HR consultant on the people side. When you work with me, your team, your payroll and your providers stay where they are, and I work alongside them.
Subscribe to my newsletter
Join my email list to hear when I release new HR resources for small businesses, plus Colorado HR updates.
Thanks, you're on my list.

The HR metrics worth tracking in a small business: headcount, turnover, early turnover, time to hire and cost per hire, with a simple monthly HR report.
Read more
One missed HR task could cost a four-person business more than $700 in a year.
Read more
Terminating an employee in Colorado: what the at-will rule allows, when the final paycheck is due, what goes in it and how to lower the legal risk.
Read moreHR Fit Check
Tell me a little about your team and I'll point you to the service that fits your business and the way of working together that suits you.
Take the Fit CheckTake the Fit Check