
Terminating an Employee in Colorado: Final Pay, At-Will Rules and Risk
Terminating an employee in Colorado: what the at-will rule allows, when the final paycheck is due, what goes in it and how to lower the legal risk.




By Allisha McCartney3 Nov 202610 min read
Subscribe to my newsletter
Join my email list to hear when I release new HR resources for small businesses, plus Colorado HR updates.
Thanks, you're on my list.
Subscribe to my newsletter
Join my email list to hear when I release new HR resources for small businesses, plus Colorado HR updates.
Thanks, you're on my list.

Engagement rarely drops all at once in a small business. A team member who used to offer ideas goes quiet in meetings, shifts get harder to cover, and someone you counted on gives notice with a reason that doesn't quite add up. By the time you notice, it's tempting to reach for a pizza lunch or a new perk and hope it sticks.
The employee engagement strategies below start with the everyday experience of working for you. In my own engagement work, the focus is "less about perks, more about the every day things". In a small business, those everyday things sit close to home: how clear each job is, how managers talk to people, whether the tools and the schedule work, and whether anything happens after someone speaks up.
Engagement is how much of themselves people bring to the job. It shows in whether they care how the work turns out, speak up when something's off and picture themselves still working for you next year. You can't measure that directly, but you can see what people do when it fades. Look for several of these signs together over a few weeks, rather than reading too much into one bad day.
Early leavers are worth a closer look. One client of mine was dealing with high turnover, especially within the first week or two of employment. I worked with them to refine their hiring and interview processes, put a better on-the-job training program in place and create a full 90-day onboarding program. That led to better retention over the long term, lower turnover in the first few weeks for "silly" reasons, fewer workplace injuries in the first few months, and better performance and customer satisfaction.
Numbers help you see the pattern before it turns into a resignation letter. If you already track turnover and early leavers, a rise in either is hard evidence for something you may have felt for months. The HR metrics for small businesses guide walks through how to work out both.
You don't need a formal program to start improving engagement. Pick two or three of the steps below, keep them up for the next four weeks and watch what changes in how people talk to you.
Set aside fifteen or twenty minutes every week or every other week, and let the team member set most of the agenda. Ask what's getting in their way and what they need from you, then write down what you agreed to do. In a small business the owner or manager is usually the only person who can clear a roadblock, so what you do after the meeting counts for more than the meeting itself.
A stay interview is a short, informal conversation with someone you want to keep, held while they still work for you instead of on their way out the door. A handful of open questions works well:
Listen more than you talk, and don't argue with the answers. Afterwards, pick one thing you heard and fix it, or explain honestly why you can't fix it yet. If you'd rather not hold these conversations yourself, stay interviews are something I can provide.
Ask the team for the one small thing that wastes their time or makes their week harder, and fix it this month. In a made-up example, the crew leads at a twelve-person landscaping company say next week's schedule only goes out on Sunday night, so nobody can plan childcare or appointments. The owner starts sending the schedule on Thursday afternoon instead, which costs nothing and shows the crew that speaking up changes something.
Whenever someone raises an issue, tell them what happened to it, even when the answer is "not yet" or "no, and here's why". Silence after feedback teaches people that speaking up is a waste of breath, and in a small team that lesson spreads fast. A specific thank-you, said soon after the work and tied to what the person actually did, fits here too and lands better than a general "great job".
Once a few habits are in place, an employee engagement program gives them a rhythm, so engagement doesn't depend on the owner remembering to ask. For a small team, the program can skip the name, the software and the budget line and run as a repeating cycle:
How often to run a formal engagement survey depends on the business and the industry. When I run one, it's no more than once a year with pulse checks in between, and sometimes every other year or every few years is the right pace. The questions I use are a combination: some are standard for all surveys and others are custom to the business. Standard questions let you compare one survey with the next, and custom ones cover what's specific to your team. If people might hold back with their name attached, an anonymous feedback channel or a suggestion box gives them another way to speak up.
Here's what a first year could look like for a made-up twenty-person dental office:
Only ask about what you're willing to act on. A survey question about pay, when pay isn't going to change this year, sets people up for disappointment, so include it only if you're ready to explain the answer honestly.
Much of what keeps people engaged costs attention more than money. If your budget is tight, put your effort here.
Clear roles. People can't do a job well when nobody agrees on what the job is. One client of mine had a job title called admin that several people were in, a catch-all position without clear roles and responsibilities. I helped break down the responsibilities into clearly defined roles with clear ownership and accountability. Afterwards, there was a better understanding of who was doing what, and the people in the new roles were more productive. When nobody knows who owns a task, the frustration can look a lot like disengagement.
Managers who can handle the people side. For many team members, the manager shapes how the job feels day to day, so a manager who gives clear, regular feedback can do more for engagement than a perk. When I follow up after a training on giving effective feedback and regular communication, one of the things I look at is feedback from team members or team member surveys before and after.
Plain, honest communication. Tell people what's going on in the business before they hear it secondhand, whether it's a new contract, a slow season or a change to the schedule. When a change needs explaining, I draft the actual communications for the business to use, based on that business, instead of handing over a template.
A way to grow. Even a small team can show people where they could go next, with new skills, more responsibility or a clear conversation about their future in the business. A team member who can see a next step has a reason to stay for it.
Recognition and team activities have their place as well, and they land better once these everyday basics are working.
Plenty of owners handle engagement themselves, and nothing here needs a consultant. Outside help starts to make sense when:
Through Employee Relations & Engagement, I help with the hard people moments and with keeping good people. An employee engagement and retention assessment with an action plan is part of that work, along with employee feedback processes and employee experience consulting. Like all my work, it starts with a conversation, and usually it starts with one project and clients move into more work from there.
If engagement on your team has been slipping and you'd like help working out why, contact me to book a consultation.
Start by listening. Hold a short one-on-one with each person, ask what makes their job harder than it needs to be, and fix one thing you hear within the month. Once people see that speaking up leads somewhere, a survey or a more formal program has something to build on.
Perks can be a nice extra, although they rarely fix the reasons people pull back, such as unclear roles, a difficult manager or a schedule that makes life harder. My own engagement work is "less about perks, more about the every day things", which is why I'd start with roles, managers and follow-through.
Put your time into the things that cost attention instead of cash: regular one-on-ones, clear roles, honest updates about the business, specific thank-yous and following through on what people tell you. Fixing one everyday annoyance, like a schedule that goes out too late, often does more than a new perk.
Small changes, like closing the loop on feedback, can change the mood in a team within weeks. Bigger shifts, such as fewer good people leaving, take longer to show up, so compare the same questions and the same numbers over several months before you decide whether something worked.
It's both, in different ways. The owner sets the tone and decides what the business will act on, while managers carry it out day to day through one-on-ones, feedback and how they run the team. In a growing business, it helps to name one person who keeps the engagement plan moving, so it doesn't stall when everyone gets busy.
Subscribe to my newsletter
Join my email list to hear when I release new HR resources for small businesses, plus Colorado HR updates.
Thanks, you're on my list.

Terminating an employee in Colorado: what the at-will rule allows, when the final paycheck is due, what goes in it and how to lower the legal risk.
Read more
Is it insubordination or a misunderstanding? How Colorado owners and managers can tell, document it, respond fairly and avoid a retaliation claim.
Read more
When a team member asks for a change at work because of a disability or pregnancy, here's what Colorado employers need to know: who's covered, the interactive process and what to write down.
Read moreHR Fit Check
Tell me a little about your team and I'll point you to the service that fits your business and the way of working together that suits you.
Take the Fit CheckTake the Fit Check